May 19, 2010
The Lost and Found
Here, I just began rambling because so many things were resting heavily on my mind. I'd just had a dream that really bothered me and here it is:
I lived in what appeared to be a New York apartment building- and I've never been to New York. Two very stylish middle-aged white women came down the hallway and knocked on my door. I opened the door and they seemed to know me and they both appeared to be happy to see me. I wasn't alone- my mother seemed out of place, and she sat on the corner of the couch with a cloth over her head, clearly sulking. The women asked to see my writing, and immediately my mother spoke up and started talking about herself. The three of us ignored her and I pulled out some of my writing which was right below the glass coffee table in front of us. I was suddenly aware of how tatty everything looked in the apartment- old furniture and worn out and I was ashamed. The paper was a wide rectangle of green construction paper- something I would never use to write on- in what appeared to be a scroll. Although the paper I wrote on was actually white, I was horrified to see that I had written longhand in block lettering- in pencil and on unlined paper. I never use unlined paper and I haven't written with a pencil since childhood. They wanted me to read what I wrote but I found it very hard to do so. As I was reading aloud from left to right, the lines didn't line up and I had left mistakes all over the page. The lines were too long and I couldn't pick up where I had left off from the line above. I kept trying but I kept failing and I felt so bad. It was at that point that I saw the women looking doubtfully at me, and then Mom brightly and loudly chirped something else about herself. She seemed quite happy. Here, I felt so bad in the dream and saw no way out that I woke myself up from the dream. I never went back to sleep because it felt like a nightmare.
Meaning of the dream: Because I had been doing so much reading and thinking about narcissism I think that the dream was trying to show how- at least in some ways- my mother operated in my life. I was in an apartment, although not one that I wanted. And although I was an adult I still had my mother attached to my hip. My mother conspicuously sat there like "Cousin It" from "The Adams Family"- weird but always letting me know how depressed she was. When the women show interest in my writing- I see them as possible saviors for me- my mother happily interrupted the scene and brought the attention back to herself. My mother thoroughly discouraged anyone who had anything nice to say to me, or who she felt was taking me away from her. Actually, it was her usual jealousy and anything I did, whether it was artwork or writing or whatever she considered to be "trash." The focus always had to be on her, which is one thing I failed to see clearly in my life with her because I was so busy accommodating her and sublimating myself. It was her way to always undercut me. At the same time, I also end up writing in childlike block lettering on green construction paper - sabotaging myself. One thing that I have known about myself but have not said in therapy is that whenever I try to change the old messages- to run counter to my parents- I feel incredibly guilty. I feel that whether it is trying to lose weight or writing that I am being unfaithful to my parents. I feel as if I am coming up against the left hand of God and how dare I?! Trying a new behavior brings up a great deal of anxiety and guilt for me because I know- even though I know it was wrong- that my parents wouldn't approve. It is more important to please my stupid ass parents than to live a life independent of them. This is where so much of my resistance comes from and it is so unbelievably powerful. I would dearly love to get rid of this old shit but I don't know how. But perhaps exposing all of this putrid mess to the light is a first step to taking away the deep shame I feel around all of this, as well as the hidden reserves of rage which I have wrongly placed on myself. Damn, is this work hard or what...
Okay- here's what comes up for me or what is coming up because I want to vomit and get rid of it. It is so hard to talk about this stuff because I feel so guilty- because I allowed myself to get into these relationships because I was so needy. I am talking about my relationship with Kimberly, who is now a psychologist. I know she is one now because I met her when she was a social worker entering her post-grad education. She is one of my narcissistic relationships, like my parents and most of my friends. When I met her at ACW (The Alcohol Center for Women), her friend Clarissa was heading an eight week program for incest survivors. Back then, this was unheard of and women came from around the country to this workshop. Why was the workshop being held at ACW? At that time, no one else wanted to hold the workshop. It was thought that mainly only alcoholic women were incest survivors. Unbelievable, but true. Out of my group of twenty women, only one woman was an alcoholic and she had stopped drinking many years ago. Year after year, it was always the same, until ACW cut out all incest programs because it wasn't serving their demographic. Might have something to do with the fact that the incest programs were by far their most popular and that didn't sit right with the director who had no training in this area. The ramshackle building next door was their residence facility for alcoholic women who always turned out to be lesbian. One of my good friends was Janet, a Jewish lesbian who had lived there and dried out. She also volunteered there for a few years and she said that the only women who did live their were lesbians. So, that was another mark against the incest groups because often they weren't lesbians. So again, we weren't their population and to this day I don't believe that they serve incest survivors.
At this time in my life, I was living an extremely isolated life. It's interesting that I can't even think of when this was, but I think I was in my late thirties. I have had a life-long habit of forgetting unpleasant experiences and perhaps remembering them many years later, if at all. Back then, I was fat (say size 14) but I was dressing in clothes way too small for me. Why? I dressed exactly as my mother did- everything matched to the last button and the clothes were far too conservative which made me feel like a proper old lady. It served my mother's astonishing jealousy toward me because I "had" to weigh twenty pounds more than her and this pleased her enormously. If I tried to lose weight she had a shit fit. Why was I still at home? Because I felt "sorry" for her and I was convinced that she couldn't make it unless I was there to take care of her. After all, hadn't she ruined every relationship she had (except for the men) by cursing everyone out? But I was also there because I had so little faith in myself, so little self-esteem that I was convinced that I couldn't do anything. College meant taking away time from her. Studying was "playing" and taking time away from her. When I'd go to class she would pitch a nasty fit or say that she wanted to die and that I just didn't care. I'd have to sit down and console her for several hours and then she would be fine- until the next time- but what happened to me? It was my fault that I had to console her- everything was my fault. Why couldn't I see this? If I succeeded at anything I was not to tell her- or Dad about it because they would act like it was nothing or put me down for it. If I complained to my mother's mother ( Older Mama), it pleased her to hear that her daughter had failed at motherhood- and she'd run right back and tell my mother what I said even though I'd ask her not to. Then Mom would curse me out for talking to Older Mama. My other grandmother (father's side) only wanted to hear that I was pregnant, which is why she actually asked me if I was pregnant at age 12 when I only had a stomach ache. She never believed me, but then my grandmother outright hated me. She always said that Guy and I were "spoiled." Yeah, right.
Mom painted herself as the ultimate "victim" and it was always everyone else's fault, including mine. And no one could ever compare. Mom would put us in competition with each other when I never saw the reason for it. And since my childhood could never compare to hers I never had anything to complain about and therefore she literally was not interested. It took me a long time to see that fact.
Everyone abandoned her (including me) when it was the other way around. She'd sometimes say that she didn't understand why she said or did the things that she did but it never stopped her. I also never remember her saying that she was sorry for anything that she did- she just forgot about it. And it went back to being my fault. She, like my father did her best to ruin all of my relationships, nor did they pretend to. Oops- I got that wrong. She actually went after every man I ever dated because she wanted to make sure that I never had anything of my own. Plus, she was terribly jealous and she wanted to humiliate me. It sounds crazy, but as you know my teddy bears are ages 3 and 23. My inner children chose age 3 because this was when my life ended. And 23 because this was when my mother me hounded me so badly and threatened me so much that I just gave up my life in order to please her, hoping that if I gave up any semblance of a life she would finally love me. I'm sure that she never said this- I just interpreted it that way. Fool that I was, I never gave up trying. I find it profoundly depressing to look at all of this and realize that I never had anyone to help me, no one to talk to. It horrifies me to see how truly hideous my mother was. My therapists all thought that I was feeling sorry for myself. When Lin tells other people (including me) how incredibly strong I have been, and that even half of what I have lived through would have killed the average person, I can see that she was right. Even I didn't understand what she meant until now. Hopefully this will set me free.
Neither of my parents liked anyone in my life, whether it was a friend (male or female), teacher, therapist, minister, etc. and they let me know it. If a teacher thought well of me and say how much talent I had as a writer, Mom was always jealous, start complaining about how I was wasting time in college and that I needed to get a "real" job. But when I was interested in a "real" job which required training of any sort, she always said that I was "wasting my time." And ideal job for me was working at the post office (which I did for a time). She complained that I spent "all of my time" at my job- as if I was having fun working twelve hour days. and she immediately made plans to "fix up the kitchen" by remodeling. Since I had a job I could pay for it she would say. When I said that I wanted to save up for an apartment and a car, she said that I could do that, too, but that she had waited for a kitchen long enough. The more I read about narcissism the more depressing it is. I don't know who was worse- my mother or my father.
As I look back I rarely saw the two of them together. Whenever dad came home she would follow him into their bedroom and close the door. My brother and I were never consulted about anything so we would just pick up stakes and move and we never knew anything about it- nor why. It is interesting that for all of her reading psychological texts she never saw herself in any of them. How can that be, right? I would read them too, and while they were too advanced for me, the one thing I did glean was that they never contained a family as sick as mine. Only when I got to R.D. Laing and his books on family systems did he start to approach my family- except her never got there. His books were considered "far out" at the time and it seemed so silly to me. Mom was like a dog reading a book- she'd look at it for awhile and go on to knaw on a rawhide bone. I didn't understand that she thought that she was fine- it was actually everyone else she was trying to understand and why she was mistreated so. My conception was my great error in her life and I could never make up for that. So why did she spend nearly thirty years in therapy?
She wanted someone to complain to. No therapist was ever able to get through to her. I would tell her that a therapist wasn't a friend and that therapy was to enable you to do something with your life. She would always toss that off- it was up to the therapist to make her "feel" like doing something- except she had no intentions of ever changing. She didn't think that "changing" was the purpose of therapy, but wanting someone to eternally say that she was right in feeling the way she did. She could have written in a journal if she wanted that, but she might have inadvertently learned something.
In the same way, I never understood my father. I rarely saw him, which was just fine with me. I thought that he had changed over the many years but I can see that I was wrong. He wants to believe that he has changed but actually, he hasn't. It sounds so much better to his ears as he flatters himself- and to actually have me agree with him! He has taken on the attributes of others, such as his late brother and claimed them as his own. I believe that the reason I have found him so delightful to talk to is that he feels exempt from any responsibility for me. He is like a happy baby in his playpen when he's with me. Imagine, he doesn't have to take responsibility for fucking his three year old daughter- she hasn't said a word! Yes, I notice that she's real, real fat and I have always been extremely vain about my looks and my weight, but I just tell her to watch her weight. And yes, I notice that she never got married, but plenty of black women don't get married. And yes, she doesn't have any children, but hey- she had a couple of abortions so she is responsible for that. And yes, she is still living at home and so is Guy and he never got married or had kids either- and while this bothers me for a bit- it never lasts long! I just shake it off and go back to thinking about myself. I finally got what I always deserved. Didn't I tell Guy and Rox not to expect anything when I die because I don't have anything to give them? I've got a fancy remodeled house that I could never afford because Janet found me living in a dumpy apartment with my brother in Inglewood with my dumpy used Cutlas. Now, I've got a top of the line BMW because Janet bought it for me. I'm so proud to tell folks about Janet going to grad school and getting her degree so she could be a teacher, although I never told my daughter that I was proud of her when she was accepted to Harvard. Oops- I didn't even know about that because I didn't care. I went out all night drinking to celebrate that my daughter was going to Pepperdine although I forgot to tell her that I was proud of her. Why was she crying just because I was drunk as I drove her to school for her first day. I told her that I didn't give a shit about all this but I didn't mean it. I forgot to apologize, though. I didn't see why she was crying when I pulled her out of Pepperdine in her first quarter. I know I just showed up at the school and she didn't know that I was going to do this, but I said that Pepperdine was too expensive. Mildred told her that she could go to a junior college- what was the difference? But actually, if I were to be honest, I got sick of picking up Rox on the weekend to take her back to L.A. This was messing up my playtime/drinking weekend. And Mildred was getting on my nerves, so I let Rox take care of her and got her off my back. Of course, I am so proud of Janet! She's so much better than Mildred. After all, Janet works as a teacher, works for parks and recreation, has a business and she calls me at home every 30 minutes! When Rox and Guy come to visit she calls every ten minutes! She pays me so much attention which I love and she should be grateful to me because I accepted such a dark skinned woman as my wife and Lord knows I can't stand dark skin. At least Mildred was light-skinned and really pretty and Janet is on the homely side, so she should treat me well. You know, even though Rox gained all that weight, she is still better looking than Janet and if she just lost that weight... I always tell her how much better she looks compared to Janet...I wonder how she would feel if she knew how I really feel- Naww! She would never guess! Rox avoids kissing me on the lips though...
That's where I ended it for today. I will get to Kimberly later. I just had to let the stale air out of the balloon for now.
Thanks for reading!
2010@ Roxane Williams
Neither parent, as bright as they are/were, has any insight into their own behavior and has shown none thus far. Nor do they care. They are indeed, one-way mirrors. I saw absolutely no growth in my mother all of those years, except a turning inward and becoming incredibly bitter and hostile. My mother was incredibly abusive (verbally) the older she grew. I no longer loved my mother because there was nothing to love. In the last ten or so years of her life she was incredibly hostile to me. She started arguments with me out of the clear blue sky. I never said the right thing to her or knew what I should say. The fact that I no longer allowed her to run over me meant that we always had titanic arguments. She would curse at me viciously as if I was an evil stranger and this always surprised me. She enver apologized for any of it, but sometimes she would try to get me to empathise with her. It sickens me and saddens me and disgusts me that anyone could be so abusive and add the fact that I ultimately allowed it . I saw Guy disappearing into the walls and he had nothing in his life but his job. Mom saw that Guy was incapable of anything except working to support her. Both of us handed over our lives to her and she greedily ate them up as if she was a vampire. The only person she loathed more than me was Lin, my mentor. She hated Lin from the beginning because Lin was contradicting her messages to me- which actually wasn't even true. Mom hated that I thought so well of Lin because she was always in competition with the world and the world always had to lose. All roads had to lead back to my mother except that there was never anything healthy or loving at the center. Lin was the only person who knew my mother for what she was and she knew how destructive she was. Lin would have sessions with Mom in which she would let Mom "have it" and not pull any punches. The effect was nil for Lin was never able to break through. Mom only hated Lin even more. Forget the fact that Lin had intervened ahead of Mom's doctors and saw that Mom was heading toward a catastrophic illness. I actually had to spoonfeed Mom the drinks that Lin so strongly suggested. Mom did indeed improve enormously, but she hated Lin just the same. And while I have never said this, I will admit that Mom actually reminded me of some of the outright evil staff at Hollywood Community Hospital. In her last years, Mom would look at me as if she didn't know me. She wouldn't be this with Guy- only with me. There was an emptiness in her eyes but there was a "knowing" which I have seen and recognized in a number of people over the years- and it isn't nice. Actually- I was kind of afraid of my mother toward the end. The hatred was just so clear and she no longer even bothered to hide it. I am sure she considered me to be her ultimate abandoner- which is why with her last breath she struggled to turn to Guy and whispered "I love you" to him, but quite clearly away from me. And then she died. I tried to say that she said it to both of us, but that wasn't true. I don't understand that kind of hatefulness. I didn't like Mom, but I didn't hate her. My wish was that she woulkd somehow transform into a loving person, but after reading all of this material I can see that this was never, ever going to happen. So how strange it was when Mom died to go to AMCS and see so many people crying actual tears over Mom's death- I mean actual flowing tears! How many times did people tell me how "nice" Mom was, or how "sweet" she was or how "funny" she was? Mom's therapist wrote me a two page letter about how Mom was her favorite client and how much she would miss her. Weeks later, people would still come up to me and tell me (with tears in their eyes) how much they missed her. And here was yet another side of my narcissistic mother: as long as I was not around, my mother appeared to be self-contained, approachable, easy to talk and laugh with, charming, prepossessed. I never saw that woman- ever. I felt as though they were talking about a woman I didn't know and that was absolutely correct. All of my life, I knew Mom to be someone who "couldn't get along with people" because that was what she told me. Whenever I was with Mom around other people, she was incredibly withdrawn, impossible to talk to except for a few moments. Later, she was deeply hostile and showed it. She cursed out the professors at Antioch University where we both were taking classes, so they had us both expelled. Mom had decided that most of the people of the class were jealous of her and so there you go. Neither Guy nor I or Dad could ever control Mom because when she was angry she- nothing stopped her. She did once tried to shoot Dad over some small infraction that she later laughed about. She fired six shots at Dad's head- they sailed over his head on a Friday night on LaBrea Ave. in front of our house. The street was incredibly crowded, but Mom just kept on firing. This sounds completely abnormal because it was. She always acted first and thought later, if at all. Nor did she ever feel guilty about this episode. So, while everybody is talking and mourning this woman at AMCS, I don't even recognize her. I was particularly pissed when I was told over and over, how "lucky" I was to have such a mother. Lucky my ass. Is it really that difficult for a therapist-in-training to see that when a client appears to be charming and companionable but refuses to change and blames everyone else for their problems that there might be a problem here? Or when a client would rather joke away their fifty minutes rather than do the actual work of therapy that there is something wrong with this picture?Perhaps it is easier to chat away the time with a non-working client because you have other things to think about- like yourself? A client like Mom does make collecting those hours easier, that's for sure. And while I really liked Mom's therapist- she seemed like a nice older therapist who had probably gotten the nerve to switch over from teaching- she clearly didn't have a clue who she was dealing with. And yet, I have some sympathy. I once watched a program with a man who was utterly charming. He was an complete delight. Sort of heavy, but still very attractive. He did run his hand over his bald head and lamented the loss of his hair, which at one time was quite lush. He was extremely intelligent and could talk in-depth about a number of subjects. He realized that it was probably best if he wasn't "let out" because he had murdered one of the other prisoners. He said he did it because "the other guy had more hair and he was also stupid." He was also bored. But he was also arrested at age 12 and imprisoned for life because he had tortured, molested and murdered four children, all under the age of five. He said that he was planning his fifth murder of a child who was one years old and already had him picked out. I'll always remember the picture of him when he was arrested- an extremely good-looking boy whose eyes were frighteningly empty, vacant and evil. He was known as one of the youngest and worst psychopaths in Canada. He was currently residing in a hospital for psychopaths. Which leads me to Kimberly...
No comments:
Post a Comment