Yes, I''m stuck, and I'm back to this old problem again. I thought it was better to write about it than to sit and stew over the problem. Get it out in the open, so there I am. Imagine- I learned to love to edit. It is an entirely different task than writing, and and yet it has it's own peaks and valleys.
When I wrote poetry, I had read a large number of different works of petry, looking for writing which I liked. I further decided on why I liked it- what "spoke" to me. Beyond that, I looked at just what about that work stood out for me. It was usually the word choices, the cadence and the rhythm of the work.
I found that I was quite fond of writers from three different areas of the world- Russia, England and Jamaica. Very different styles to be had here. My writing teacher wanted me to stick with the female writers, but I branched out to the male writers, as well. I wanted to see what, if anything was different between the sexes.
I had a weekly appointment with my therapist, and there were always several copies of The New Yorker magazine in the waiting room. I found myself attracted - not to the articles- but to the cartoons and the poetry. I'd tear out a number of these from the magazines, and yes, I was a thief. It is in my Fourth Step Inventory, if you want to know.
As I looked over my little collection of filched poetry, I noticed something quite striking: the male poets tended to write about...nothing. A rock, a bird who never went anywhere, and lots of work on streams. Nothing was ever happening! The work felt static to me, full of abstractions. And I noticed how few women poets ever got published in this magazine- unless they wrote about a rock or birds who never took flight.
Back to my women poets, at last! These writers spoke of things that were familiar to me- which meant "feelings." One poem was about an activist who was sitting in her flat, with a drink in her hand, alone after all of the hullabaloo of the protest of the day. She defined herself by what she did, but after that- what was her life about- really? Her aloneness reminded her of her mother and how they weren't so different after all. She thought of how small her mother's life had grown- so small that her mother had grown childlike over the years- and she saw herself taking that same road. All of that meaning in a short poem. That was what I wanted!
Which is how I crafted my poetry. My earlier poems were wordy and grand, with big thoughts about even larger events. It was too big, too large. I wanted to edit the work into smaller events which within that space held larger moments. It could never be static, however, for something had to happen- something had to change. The internal thoughts were not enough. And no abstractions. That might work for some others, but not for me.
I always needed the "beingness" and the feelings. If I sat in one place, like the poem above, then I needed to be traveling in my mind. I needed something to happen. And so I learned to edit out all of the extraneous words until I got to the essence of of the work.
I also learned that I don't write "pretty." I knew someone in my writing group who wrote long, beautiful poetry- four or five single-spaced pages. She had an extensive vocabulary. We were to edit the works by this time, and I remember sitting there feeling inadequate.
Yes, the words were pretty, but what did they mean? What was she saying? What is this wordy poem about? The work always felt terribly complex and we were all to say something flattering about the work and then what needed "help." This group was full multiple-degreed women who enjoyed picking up yet another degree on their weekends. And they were ever so self-congratulatory in an 'umble sort of way. I suppose that I was the unspoken peon- but they even took credit for that, for I had to be very bright and a "woman of color." It made them feel very democratic when actually they weren't at all.
When they all brought out their huge master calendars at the end of our meetings- they discussed what part of the world they would be visiting during the coming month. I didn't have a master calendar because I didn't know what one was.
What I learned from this experience was that the "pretty" poetry was about nothing- as I always felt. The rock would sit in the stream with water flowing over it. Next month, a flower would sit in a stream of water, but held fast. Was there a deeper meaning to the flower in the steam? No. I finally dared to say that I didn't understand the poetry. Lots of pretty words, but I just didn't get it. Nothing was really happening. These were shocking words, but I'd had it by that time. A few women also admitted that they had said that they understood her work, but actually they hadn't. Nothing was happening. I always knew that I was the best writer in the group. But it was never "polite" work that I wrote. I had no "pretty" words in my poetry. Things happened. I realized that I was surrounded by work which was static and saying nothing.
I left the group under unpleasant circumstances because I dared to speak my true opinion. I just never fit in- and I no longer wanted to. And remembering this experience, it reminds me that when it comes to editing I must be true to myself.
I can't edit with my eye on the end result because I'm not there yet. I need to remember what is important to me and how I write. I need to say "Go" and let it take me where it wants. I know well the proces of what feels right and how I achieve that state. It never happens in a straight line. My goal is not to write in abstractions nor to bother with the "pretty" words which mean nothing to me, anyway.
I am reminded of what I know is important to me and I know my strengths. I will edit with that in mind. And now, it is time to open my notebook, and begin...