Saturday, August 8, 2009

I Am a Camera

"I Am A Camera" is the 1955 non-musical version of "Cabaret" with Liza Minnelli. It starred Julie Harris who also won a Tony for the role of Sally Bowles. The movie comes from Christopher Isherwood's "Berlin Stories" and there the comparisons basically end. You would have to read "Berlin Stories" to understand how much was edited from both films.

For example, I always wondered what Sally Bowles was doing in pre-Hitlerian Berlin. There was always something "ambiguous" about her character that I couldn't ever pinpoint, because none of her vague reasons to remain there made sense to me. It wasn't until I read "Berlin Stories" that I understood that Sally Bowles was actually a drag queen. Okay, now that made more sense. Isherwood had to write in "code" because of the harsh laws against homosexuality in England. Even Isherwood is a nominal character here, and yet he is known as a "confirmed bachelor" rather than as the gay man he was.

But this is a review of both "I Am a Camera" and "Cabaret"- specifically the characterization of Sally Bowles. And there really is no comparison. "Cabaret" is a landmark in musical theater with the great Liza Minnelli, with great songs and dances which will always remain classic and modern. "I Am a Camera" was filmed in a bland black-and-white for $1.59. Thankfully, it stars the great Julie Harris and Laurence Harvey who is at least a far superior actor to Michael York.

But to view both films was a revelation to me. In "I Am a Camera" I finally understood Sally Bowles. Julie Harris much more capably showed how hard she had to work to pretend that everything was light, easy and okay, "gay." Here, Bowles was quirky, confused, naive, yet lots of fun no matter where she lived. She was playing a role in her life and she couldn't find just where she belonged in life. The chief thing that Harris was able to achieve was that genuine "magical" quality that is so difficult to convey. It always amazes me that anyone can look at the tiny and plain-Jane Julie Harris wearing a beret and holding a cigarette lighter and see "magic", but you do. I did. Even in 1955, this film wrongly received the infamous review, "Me No Leica" (which was pretty damn clever, I'll admit.) But I resist and desist.

Yes, "I Am A Camera" was in parts too pretentious for words and even now, I cringe. The people who made this film seemed to be proud as piss knowing that they were working with this great source material.

But when I think of the character of Sally Bowles, I can only think of five -time Tony Award winner Julie Harris.
And if you read closely, you will notice that much of the dialogue from "Cabaret" was directly lifted from the Isherwood material.

Call me old-fashioned, but I found the heart of Sally Bowles in this forgotten, but noteworthy film.

No comments: